In my summary of the chapters one and two I told you at the end something about the differences of Jonas' culture and ours. In the chapters three, four and five I noticed more strange things, which I want to explain to you now.
First I want to tell you some similarities. The little children have something which is called "comfort objekt". I guess it is something like stuffed animal (Kuscheltier) for us.
They also have a almshouse, they call it House of the Old. But in distinction from our culture you don't die there. When you had a successful live you come into the Releasing Room. Nobody knows what exactly it is.
Now I start with the differences. At the beginning of chapter three you get to know that Jonas' eyes are different from nearly all the eyes from the other community members. There are only two other persons who have pale eyes instead off dark ones too: a female Five and the newchild who belongs to Jonas' family unit now (of course it is not a full family member, because Jonas' parents allready have two children, it is somethink like a foster child.) When Lily mentions this to Jonas he fumes at her. „It was not a rule, but was considered rude to call attention to things that were unsettling or different about individuals.“ (p.23; ll.12-13)The children were not educated to develop their own personality, they should be like all the others, nothing special.
Then, when Lily talks about her wish to become a birthmother, you get to know that the parents don't raise their own children. They've got special birthmothers for that who are allowed to give birth to three children and after that they have to do hard physical work until they get to the House of the Old. They don't even see their babies.
The next thing is that there are announcements for every offence against the law. These announcements are made by a Speaker and have to be made through something like loudspeaker, because all the people in the community can hear them. And without saying any name everyone knows who broke the rule.
When the children become an Eight they get free hours in which they can do what they want. They should use this freedom to help the community and test different jobs they are interested in.
In the mornings the families have a special ritual: they talk about their dreams they had last night.In chapter five Jonas dreamed of a girl called Fiona. He wanted to wash her (like he does to the Olds when he is at their house) and he wanted her to be naked. Only for the Olds it is allowed to be seen from someone else naked. His mother called this dream the beginning of the Stirrings. He has to take a pill so that this won't happen again, which he has to take every day from now on.
At least here are some rules from the community:
1.You are only allowed to ride a bicycle when you are older than nine.
2.You are not allowed to take any food home.
3.Hair ribbons are to be neatly tied at all times.
At the end of the post here are the, I think, two most important questions to these chapters:
1. What exactly are Sterrings (For me it sounds like to have some romantic feelings for a person) and why aren't you allowed to have them?
2. How do they make babies when not even doctors are allowed to see naked people?
Hey. It's a really good idea to make a list about the rules in the community. But I want focus your questions. Your first question "What exactly are Stirrings ... and why aren't you allowed to have them?" I think that your first impression is quiet good. And to the second point: We can only imagine why they are forbidden, but I think that these are some strong feelings and they would disturb the system and they would carry the individualism. Yes to your second question I don't have any idea. maybe we will discover it in the following chapters. I enjoyed reading your post. ;)
ReplyDeleteI think "Stirrings" are sexual feelings and because you are not allowed to give birth to babies -so you are not allowed to have sex with anybody- the Elders don't want you to have this "Stirrings". The pill Jonas takes from his mum should control this normal instinct of humans, as everything should be controlled in the community. Also that there are just a few babies and the Birthmothers give birth to them. So they can control the number of community members -like they do with the "realeasing" of the Olds and so on...
ReplyDeleteThe second question:
Do you mean the doctors like midwives? I think there is an exception like for the labor in the "House of Old". When they wash the old men they are allowed to see them naked -why should midwives or doctors not be allowed to see people naked?
And additionally to that: Do you really think they need doctors? I think there are no ill people, because they are released as a baby if they are not perfect...and anyone who is not perfect will be released...I don't think they need doctors ;)
So we're in a society which is totally controlled by rules. Knowing the rules is important and apparently second nature even to young children.. The reason this book is a "page turner" (are you familiar with this idea?) is because we always want to know more about this alien society.
ReplyDeleteI think your title of the post captures quite well what you describe in your text. Especially the "Releasing Room" is something I wonder about - Why does nobody know what exactly it is?
ReplyDeleteAnother thing is very important in the society - Sameness. As it is descibed well by the qoute you give ("It was not a rule, but was considered rude to call attention to things that were unsettling or different about individuals.“) That leaves basically no freedom at all- I'm confused how people can live in a society like this.
I like your questions at the end of the post - they seem so natural to us; but in "the Giver"'s society these questions never come up because everything seems to be regulated.. I